Tag: 1984

I’d seen this advertised and, finding that listening to this wouldn’t cost an Audible credit, I thought I’d give it a go.

1984, of course, is a classic—for me, it stands next to Brave New World and The Handmaid’s Tale as one of the three greatest dystopian novels—so any adaptation has to be good. And, overall, I think they did a good job.

As a listening experience, it was enjoyable. Andrew Scott is chillingly perfect as O’Brien, bringing that mix of intellectual authority and sinister menace that makes the character so unsettling. Andrew Garfield does solid work as Winston too, though I did find myself questioning whether he played Winston as a bit too much of a wet lettuce (so to speak). He felt a bit more subservient than how I remember him when I first read the book.

And I knew it was Matt Belamy who did the sound design just from listening. You can hear all that paranoia that’s been baked into Muse’s music over the years (and, of course there’s the little cameo moment for The Resistance). It was like Belamy had been auditioning for this role for years; and, given how obviously inspired Muse have been by dystopian literature, it was a good fit. If I had any criticism, it’s that Belamy probably played it a bit safe. I would have loved him to lean even harder into the dystopian atmosphere he’s so good at creating.

The adaptation does okay at condensing Orwell’s dense novel while keeping all the essential elements intact. The core concepts (newspeak, doublethink, Big Brother’s surveillance) all come through clearly without feeling rushed or oversimplified.

Was it perfect? No, I can’t say it was. Winston’s character development and his fluctuating relationship with Julia doesn’t quite work in this compressed version. The significant changes in how they feel about each other and the resistance don’t feel natural. And, I certainly could have done without Garfield’s heavy breathing right in my ears during the sex scene. Some things work better on the page than whispered directly into your headphones…

I’d take the original over the adaptation any day of the week. But overall it was a solid effort and an enjoyable listening experience.